Gears of War E-Day Review: A great game, but lacking in innovation

, by Thibaut

Gears of War E-Day Review: A great game, but lacking in innovation

It has taken seven long years to see the return of this cult classic franchise from the XBOX 360 era. Back in 2006, Gears of War instantly became a must-play franchise in the third-person shooter genre, with its highly effective cover system, epic cinematography, a remarkable co-op mode, and an addictive multiplayer experience. These are the qualities that The Coalition has sought to revive with this brand-new installment steeped in nostalgia.

Let's be clear: Gears of War: E-Day is a project conceived first and foremost to please existing fans. It’s a prequel designed to let diehards of the series relive one of its most iconic moments. It remains to be seen whether the magic formula still hits the mark 20 years later… The future of the franchise and its studio may well hinge on it, given the restructuring at XBOX. Without further ado, it’s time to embark on a true suicide mission!

The power of tension and emotion

In the collective imagination, Gears of War is first and foremost a great stress reliever that doesn’t skimp on massive, destructive weapons and plenty of gore. While E-Day doesn’t shy away from all that violence, it also takes the time to tell a story that’s less trivial than it would seem. We find Marcus Fenix haunted by the ghosts of his past, just as Emergence Day has arrived. Without going into spoilers here, this event sees the Locust horde (the monsters of the series) emerge from the ground to wipe out humanity. It’s a defining moment in the franchise’s timeline, and it’s portrayed here in the most stunning way.

The Coalition has recounted these dark hours through the eyes of Marcus and his Gears squad. Each soldier has their own personality, painful past, and inner struggles, which makes them endearing protagonists and in turn leads to sequences of almost unexpected emotion. At times, we’re a far cry from the brutish reputation that’s marred the series for two decades now. Fans will undoubtedly shed a few tears, and newcomers may well be moved by certain dialogues. The writing may not quite reach the level of The Last of Us or Red Dead Redemption 2, mind you, but the effort to make this blockbuster more human is commendable nevertheless.

This new Gears of War offers some truly emotional moments! Marcus Fenix seems more human than ever

Get ready for an epic adventure!

You have to admit that Gears of War: E-Day has all the makings of the quintessential AAA game, starting with its stunning visuals, powered by Unreal Engine 5 at its peak. Whether in Quality or Performance mode on the Xbox Series X, every moment of the game is a visual treat. Special mention goes to the Balanced mode at 40 FPS, which offers the perfect compromise.

The frame rate remains virtually steady, the environments and characters are perfectly modeled, and the lighting adds real character to certain sequences. The experience is just as satisfying online, with a single 60 FPS mode that ensures dynamic gameplay and ever-present responsiveness.

Only a slight flickering effect is visible on elements like fences. Nothing too serious, mind you… The city of Kalona, where most of the story takes place, also crumbles before our eyes as the hours go by. Buildings are gutted, the ground collapses, and entire neighborhoods are even wiped off the map a few chapters later. This destruction serves the story and can even function as environmental storytelling, as you can truly feel the weight of war and the chaos that follows. Nothing has been left to chance in terms of presentation, and no visual glitches mar this grim spectacle.

The chainsaw still wreaks havoc in close combat! The shooting mechanics are right on point A scene in a police station that’s a bit reminiscent of Resident Evil A city dying before our eyes

Rock-solid gameplay

Controller in hand, Gears of War: E-Day also makes a great impression. While Marcus and his teammates move with a certain heaviness (all thanks to the Gears armors), the game is a real delight in terms of controls. You can feel the power of every weapon and every melee attack. The famous chainsaw makes a comeback and delivers a real sense of satisfaction with every kill. Your character moves from one piece of cover to another at lightning speed, and the menus are exceptionally user-friendly. Here again, everything has been designed to maintain the breakneck pace that defines Gears of War, whether in the corridor sections or more open areas.

The game features chapters that encourage exploration. Between mission objectives, you can explore the streets of Kalona to find secret items, weapon mods in hard cases, or complete side activities. These are fairly repetitive, as they almost always involve protecting civilians by slaughtering hordes of Locusts. The rewards are always mods, which isn’t very motivating. The hard-to-read map also detracts a bit from the fun of the game. In our opinion, these open sections are largely dispensable overall.

Multiplayer matches are dynamic and incredibly engaging The cover system hits the mark once again

Always better with friends

In the past, Gears of War built its reputation on co-op and multiplayer. In this particular case, this brand-new installment invites us to play through the campaign with up to three friends. This is the best way to experience the game, as it’s steeped in co-op at every level. In single-player mode, the AI allies are hit-or-miss. Our Gears can be highly effective in combat, but they have an annoying tendency to stand in front of our crosshairs, block our path, or even fire pointlessly at a wall. This also applies to the Locusts, who are capable of changing cover or coming in for close-quarters combat, but are also prone to freezing in place and acting as bullet magnets. Co-op is therefore the way to go.

As for multiplayer, it remains fairly standard, featuring 4v4 PvP, team deathmatch, and territory capture, all with playlists that rotate through all available modes. Ranked matches weren’t yet available at the time of this review (they’re coming on October 13, 2026). Additionally, the Horde Siege mode places you in a squad of four players and comes in three formats. You must complete objectives in a fairly open environment before exfiltrating via helicopter. Again, nothing particularly revolutionary, but it works very well within the Gears of War universe. The seasonal system will refresh the content with new maps and features.

The game features some truly epic moments and vistas

A healthy dose of nostalgia?

Ultimately, Gears of War: E-Day has a distinct XBOX 360/PS3 vibe, which is both its greatest strength and weakness. Those accustomed to third-person shooters from this pivotal era in gaming will be right at home, and there’s a sense of minimalism that was palpable on that generation of consoles. You move forward, take cover, shoot, then rinse and repeat. Some might find this tedious, especially in a campaign that can easily run around fifteen hours.

The Coalition’s title has a simplistic, even downright basic feel to it and can lack variety. What it does, it does well. But in 2026, many are hoping for more originality and risk-taking, especially from a game that took seven long years to develop. E-Day does none of that, content instead to put the player in a comfortable bubble and carry them through to the end of a campaign that is, truth be told, really well done.

Some Locusts will give you the chills A confident hero, but haunted by a troubled past

Tested on Xbox Series X. See our rating policy here.

8/10

Gears of War: E-Day seems primarily aimed at fans and those feeling nostalgic for the early 2010s. There’s nothing revolutionary to report here, but everything has been polished to perfection to offer a game with solid content that’s confident in its strengths and worthy of its legacy. While at times a bit by-the-book in its execution, it makes up for it with stunning graphics, exceptional cinematography, nonstop action, and a sometimes surprising storyline driven by characters that are pretty complex.

Sadly, this may not necessarily be enough to secure the franchise’s future: as it struggles to reinvent itself, it risks missing the mark with certain audiences. It would be a shame, however, to miss out on a popcorn game like this one, which simply invites us to switch off our brains and enjoy the spectacle from start to finish.

  • + Stunning graphics
  • + Responsive and limitless gameplay
  • + Plenty of content to enjoy, both in the campaign and multiplayer
  • + Co-op is still top-notch
  • + Seeing the destruction of Kalona
  • + A great cast
  • - To put it simply, AI can be annoying and dumb
  • - The game follows a fairly conventional formula
  • - The more open sections are rather predictable
  • - There are too many weapon mods

You probably also gonna like...

  • Gears of War: E-Day has reportedly sold over 400,000 units

    Given its substantial budget, which is estimated at several hundred million dollars, Gears of War: E-Day was, on paper, a game that would be very difficult to make profitable. The latest figures released by Tom Warren of The Verge seem to paint a rather concerning picture. According to these figures,…

  • Gears of War: E-Day would have cost XBOX over $500 million, and that's without marketing

    The road to profitability looks long and, let's be for real here, completely out of reach for Gears of War: E-Day. A new report cites a colossal budget for The Coalition’s title, which will likely never recoup its costs. While rumors had already suggested a budget exceeding $400 million, Kotaku went…

  • The Gears of War: E-Day servers were hit by a DDoS attack

    It was an eventful weekend for Gears of War: E-Day. Players experienced disconnections, connection issues, and numerous service outages. The Coalition has since issued a statement explaining the cause of the problem. The game was the victim of a DDoS (or denial-of-service) attack that has not yet been…